LED Grow Lights – Do They Actually Work?
About a decade ago, interest in LED lights reached an all time high!
We've got NASA to thank. Their scientists did loads of research into LED's, hoping they could be used to grow plants in space.
For indoor gardeners, the potential is enormous.
Now, in 2012, and you can get a 'decent' LED for £90.
But are they any good? We decided to do our own tests:
So, NASA did lots of research on LED lights. You'd expect there to be plenty of test results out there.
Nope. Far from it.
The only results NASA shared on their site were from a study into how LED lights healed human skin.
Not much help.
Most of the evidence we found online came from LED light manufacturers.
Funny that. Hardly unbias.
Other articles got basic facts wrong (like the wavelengths of light needed). How were we meant to trust sources like that?
The most convincing evidence came from a grow diary! They had a $1,200 LED setup. A few lines into the article, and the company reported they couldn't even grow full sized tomatoes.
If they couldn't do it on $1,2000, what chance did a £90 LED have?
Their findings definitely explain the lack of legitimate research.
We have come across some anecdotal claims. Some are really bold:
- LED lights claim to outperform a 400W light system
- A 90W LED can replace a 600W HPS
- G3 LEDs are nearly 100% efficient at plant growth (10 x that of an HID light)
- High efficiency, using 85% less power
We'll leave it there...anyone else hear alarm bells?
Most of these claims seems unlikely. How could you possibly get more PAR light from a 90W light than from a 600W?
Call us sceptics, but we weren't convinced LED's were as magical as made out to be.
We decided to carry out our own tests: